Setting the Record Straight: Part 3

This is the third blog in a series in which we refute common misconceptions about homeownership.


Theory 3: Lower- income homeowners erode their equity gains through excessive borrowing.

Another criticism of homeownership as an investment is that lower income homeowners might diminish their wealth gains through excessive borrowing. For low- and moderate- income households to recognize the benefit of accruing equity, they must not borrow that money back for other uses. Allison Freeman and Janneke Ratcliffe from UNC’s Center for Community Capital used data from the Community Advantage Program (CAP) to determine whether or not low- and moderate- income homeowners increase their levels of borrowing because of the accumulation of home equity.

Freeman and Desmarais found that home equity of more than $150,000 corresponds to an average increase of $1,000 in credit card debt. However, “the accumulation of equity over time shows a smaller relationship to the accumulation of credit card debt.” Notable borrowing against the home occurred only when equity levels exceeded $100,00 and never reached a scale that would decimate equity based wealth.

The study concluded that while there appears to be some association between the accumulation of large amounts of equity (more than $150,000) and increased debt, “there is no evidence that debt accumulation by CAP homeowners offsets the wealth- building effect of home equity.”

For more information on this study, click here.